Online private placements – an oxymoron?
A private placement is a fundraising strategy that is exempt from the full securities registration process and therefore much simpler and cheaper to do within the law. The basic rule of private placements is that you may not solicit investment from the general public – you can only solicit people you already know. Generally, you must have a pre-existing relationship with them dating from before you start to offer securities.
What is and is not general solicitation can get tricky! Especially if you decide to make your private offering of securities using a third party web-based platform. Beware! Don’t assume that these services know what they are doing and are in compliance with the law. If they screw up, you could be on the hook to return the money you raised using their platform.
What questions should you ask before deciding whether to use one of these platforms?
1. Is the operator of the platform a licensed broker-dealer? If not, it can be risky to post your private placement on their site.
Section 15 of the 1934 Exchange Act requires persons that effect securities transactions on behalf of others to register as broker-dealers. However, if the web-based platform is merely serving as a passive intermediary that facilitates the introduction of buyers and sellers, it may be able to operate legally without a broker-dealer license. The types of activities to watch out for if the platform does not have a license include offering advice and information, handling funds, assisting with negotiations, and receiving fees based on a percentage of the purchase price.
2. How is the operator of the platform finding investors for the site? Is it being done in a way that could look like general solicitation? For example if the public web site invites potential investors to view specific offerings, this could be a general solicitation and all un-registered offerings on the site would be illegal.
3. Is access limited to accredited investors? If not, it is necessary to provide an extensive private placement memorandum to potential investors and there is more risk of runnning afoul of the law.
4. How are investors screened? How does the platform ensure that investors are really accredited and are making other required representations such as a statement that they are not purchasing for re-sale? Generally speaking a lengthy questionnaire is required to determine whether the potential investor is suitable – having them check a box stating that they are accredited is not enough.
5. Once investors are given access to the site, are they allowed to view offerings that were already listed? If so, this could be deemed general solicitation.
6. Are detailed records kept to ensure that the requisite pre-existing relationships can be documented if necessary?
7. Has the platform secured a “no action letter” from state and/or federal regulators assuring that the regulators will not bring an action against them?
Thanks! This is really informative.